When I was an adolescent, I yearned to play the drums; I begged my parents to buy me a kit and clear out the garage to all me a space to create and launch my career. The latter part of that wish was total fantasy as we were one of the only families in our neighborhood who did this weird thing: we parked our cars in the garage. Having a piano already in the home, mom and pops made me a deal: take one year of piano to learn to read music and show my commitment, and they would buy a drum set for me. Four grueling months into piano lessons, I gave up my dream - long on yearning, woefully short on commitment. They were grueling for my teacher (my future sister-in-law) and slightly discomforting for the rest of the family who had to listen to me practice.
While the drums are the heartbeat of most of the music I like, being a member of the first generation of MTV kids, I am equally fascinated watching that member of the band who is usually pushed to the back of the stage. As I’ve had this fascination for 40+ years, I’ve come to put drummers in one of four groups:
- The Cheshire Cat: whatever the rest of the band is doing, this drummer is always in the background with a wry, lopsided grin, and nothing is affecting them. They blissfully play on, perhaps mug at the camera, and give you the sense they’re just happy to be there whether the gig is a sold-out stadium or an intimate club not exactly filled to capacity. In this group I place the likes of Ringo Starr, Jon Farriss, and Charlie Watts.
- The Professor: their dedication to the craft, the art, the religion of percussion is serious and sober. With their painstakingly arranged kits, they compose and deliver an eloquent lecture of sound to all around them by arranging beats that enthrall everyone listening and causing some to look at them as if they’re gods. Neil Peart and Stewart Copeland are two such professors.
- The Storm: this group is what most people picture when they think of drummers - a force of nature whose energy would frighten you if their rhythms and soul-thumping sounds didn’t pick you up and deliver you to another place. Every part of their body is a blur; you’re equally energized and enervated just watching them. The National Weather Service should use the names of John Bonham, Keith Moon, Alex Van Halen, and Tommy Lee to designate hurricanes.
- The Calm: equally powerful as the storm, these musicians subdue it. They sit among their kit upright and slightly rigid, letting the power of the storm only manifest itself in controlled but relaxed movements coming from their arms and hands, tattooing a beat you not only hear but feel in your soul. You invariably wonder how the fierce tempos and seismic rhythms can be created by an individual who looks so serene and untroubled. With great pleasure, I watch artists like Larry Mullen, Jr. and Roger Taylor let percussion take center stage.
Who are your favorites, and in what category would you put them?